By Jeff Bell.
What do you believe motivates the people you are leading?
Your position on this matter will largely determine how you behave as a leader.
For instance, if you believe that people always need guidance, will work only under sufferance, cannot be trusted, are self-oriented, are less intelligent and lazier than most, working for money alone—you will probably be drawn to micro-management and a system of reward and punishment.
This is Theory X—the X denoting the crossed arms of someone who resists life.
Your behaviours are likely to be centred on strict control, tight processes, rewards and punishments. Your organisational structure is likely to have many layers and silos. Organisational roles and titles will be paramount. Interpersonal relationships will mostly be restrained within those layers and silos.
As that Theory X leader, you may take the hard approach where your favoured tools will be close supervision, intimidation and immediate punishment. Alternatively, you may employ the soft approach where you would employ leniency and less strict rules. Realistically, you may settle somewhere in the middle between hard and soft.
By contrast, if you believe that people can be self-directed, will work with self-generated joy, are trustworthy, are team- or organisation-oriented are more intelligent and energised than most, working for satisfaction (in addition to money)—you will probably be drawn to hands-off leadership.
This is Theory Y—the Y denoting the raised arms of someone who embraces life.
Your behaviours are likely to be centred on enhancing self-control, flexible processes, very limited use of rewards and punishments. Your organisational structure is likely to have fewer layers with a macroprocess aligned with customer delivery and no silos. Organisational roles and titles will be secondary to sound workflow and communications. Interpersonal relationships will spread vertically and horizontally.
This doesn’t mean a laissez-faire approach—authority, accountability and decision-making will be defined, so that people know just how much free-rein they may take.
As a Theory Y leader, your efforts may well be directed to developing for each person:
- autonomy—developing the skills and allowing the authority for people to exercise their own judgement ;
- mastery—supporting the development of the highest skills and decision-making;
- purpose—providing a meaningful role within a business that does good work in the community.
(This triumvirate is the basis of another model developed at MIT—Google Daniel Pink.)
The X, Y model was developed by Douglas Macgregor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and expanded in his 1960 book The Human Side of Enterprise. For a long period, he worked under Abraham Maslow who developed the seminal Hierarchy of Needs model in 1943.
But can it be as simple as your view of motivation? For instance, what type of business are you leading?
A business that turns out a physical product, allowing zero or minimal variation in a strict process may well call for application of the X model. The real challenge for leadership in this environment is to find ways to apply Theory Y.
A business that delivers a service, that can tolerate or even require variation from a process in which people can use their discretion may be a natural fit for Theory Y. The excesses will come from this model may well be reined in by some application of Theory X.
Concomitant with these theories, the chances are that leadership demands that you are high up on Maslow’s hierarchy. He posited that self-actualizing people focus on problems outside themselves; have a clear sense of what is true and what is false; are spontaneous and creative; and are not bound too strictly by social conventions.
He found that such people are independent and private in terms of their personal environment and culture. These individuals also were comfortable being alone and had healthy personal relationships. with only a few close friends and family rather than a large number of less-deep relationships.
How you see the people before you—and their motivations; what type of business you are leading; to what extent you are self-actualised will all play into your leadership style, capacity and effectiveness.
Sorry for the simplistic hook. Being X or Y is not as simple as A, B, C.