By Jeff Bell.
Many business owners had an overoptimistic view of the value of their business and did not appreciate the length of time needed to bring it to market. These were the leading points presented by business valuation specialists Robyn Crombie and Janie Quinn in a Guest Conversation with members and guests of Band of Leaders Australia.
Robyn (pic left) spoke of the value gap—the difference between what an owner thought their business was worth and what the market was prepared to pay. She said that the owner needed to work on a number of issues for up to 5 years in pursuit of the best return at sale.
Chief among these issues was an understanding of the factors that drove the business capitalisation rate for the business. This may be, for example, a multiplier of 3 times EBIT. But macro business environment issues, such as the height of Covid-induced uncertainty, may cause downward pressure that resulted in a multiplier of only 1.5.
BoLA is a peer membership group for business owners and chief executives. Our purpose is to develop outstanding leadership in a stimulating, confidential setting, through a full-day group meeting and one coaching session monthly. Inviting Guest Conversations is a key activity in our group meeting.
In the days before the 2-hour session, members had completed an online business valuation scorecard which highlighted their advantages and revealed shortcomings or lack of awareness.
Based on this data, Robyn and Janie then led the discussion of a methodology to add value to the sale:
- Taking the long view—having 3 years of well-documented business performance and allowing perhaps 2 years for preparation for sale.
- Writing and implementing an active business plan.
- Analysing sustainable “normal” profits, including a schedule of add-backs and expenses.
- Concentrating on factors that drive up the capitalization rate eg. rent, location, contract values, revenue, writing a business owner’s manual.
- Engagement of an accountant and/or business broker (who has success in your industry) early in the process to establish guidelines.
- Paying due attention to non-financial factors such as the future length of lease.
- Commissioning a paid business valuation.
- Being clear about whether the sale was to be for the company shares or for the business assets (eg goodwill, equipment).
- Articulating the unique selling point of the business and each of its products.
- Anticipating prospective buyers’ motivations.
- Optimising the Business Risk and Value Drivers.
Robyn and Janie pointed out matters that led to the sub-optimisation of value, which included:
- Low awareness of industry benchmarks and where to seek the information.
- No succession planning—thus increasing the vulnerability of the business’ leaders.
- Inadequate insurance policies that exposed the business to untenable risk.
- Low investment in staff development.
- Systems and/or software that were incapable of accurate and timely reporting.
Robyn, a Director at Armada Accountants and Advisers, is a Chartered Accountant who has been working with businesses for over 25 years to maximise their profits and growth. She is pro-active with wealth creation and asset protection for clients in construction, engineering and manufacturing, wholesaling, health professionals and high net worth families with complex structures.
She particularly enjoys working with family businesses to increase their profits and cash flow, build their business value, and have a positive impact on their wealth.
Janie, an Associate Director at Armada, is a CA and CPA with over 35 years’ experience. She consults to a large range of business types within the Small to Medium Enterprise sector including retail trade, wholesale trade, manufacturing, medical, and building & construction.
As well as providing general, tax, accounting & business advice, Janie specialises in business performance and key performance indicators management, management and board representation, business process restructuring, cash flow & profit forecasting and business valuations.
In closing, Robyn said that businesses that went on the market without adequate planning often meant a poor result at sale. If preparations had not already begun, the best time to start was now.
BoLA members will meet next on Friday 18 March at Joondalup Country Club. Typically, our agenda includes such a Guest Conversation as above, processing of strategic opportunities raised within the group and leadership development tools and activities.
Membership applications are welcome—new groups start this year. Contact Jeff as below.