By Jeff Bell.
To be challenged can bring out the best in us—some pressure is beneficial. But being stressed or traumatised can take us down the slippery slope of declining mental health—such as anxiety, depression and self-harm, as well as damage to our physical well-being.
Last week, I described the 5 responses to trauma. We, and everyone we lead, will be subject to at least one, at any time:
- Feeling that we are under attack may cause us to defend or even counter-attack perhaps in the hope of catching the aggressor by surprise, thereby gaining an advantage. This is the Fight Response.
- If we run away, we are exhibiting the Flight Response. To avoid conflict, we protect ourself from any physical harm and perhaps from hearing anything that we may find offensive or damaging.
- While not exiting the scene, we close down. We feel perhaps isolated and dissociated, both of which will increase our anxiety, rather than our coping capacity. This is the Freeze Response.
- As we see conflict approaching, we look for ways to make it better. We seek easy answers, along the line of least resistance—saying “yes” to everything. This is the Fawn Response.
- We lose control of our autonomic nervous system. This is the Flop Response. We go limp, we faint and we may even become incontinent. All is lost; there is no hope.
So, while we acknowledge our programming as humans, we also need to accept that we have the force of free will—we’re not the helpless victims of our own chemistry.
Chinese military strategist, Taoist philosopher, and general in the 6th century BC, Sun Tzu, had a great point of view, way back then:
“Supreme excellence consists in breaking the enemy’s resistance without fighting.”
And he could well have added, without fleeing, freezing, fawning or flopping. Clearly, we are looking for a sixth possibility: the Resolution Response.
This will mean control of our initial impulse, as above, in the pursuit of a better outcome.
Conflict too, may bring out the best in us—if used creatively, it can deliver benefits for both parties. This means bringing it into the open, seeking to deal with it quickly, openly and fairly for all concerned. Whether resolution is possible will depend on the awareness level of the players and the circumstances on the day. Also as there will probably be an imbalance of power, a mediator will be required—a skilled player, who can remain calm and effective.
For the purposes of this exercise, let’s assume that you are that mediator:
- Analyse the dynamics of the conflict. Who’s involved and which of the 5 stress responses is each taking—fighting, fleeing, fawning, freezing or flopping? Establish yourself as an independent mediary through explaining the intents (to make it safe and deliver justice for all) and then gaining agreement to proceed.
- Clarify what the disagreement is. Give each party a private hearing about the history, the issue and the desired outcome. Stress that your role is to design a fair outcome for all parties, including the business you represent. Point out that “getting everything you want” may not be possible.
- Establish a common goal. Ask each party to state what their grievance is and what they would like to get from a mediation. Ask each party to re-state what they have heard from the other party and get confirmation from the speaker. State your recommendation and seek mutual commitment.
- Discuss steps to reach the goal. Ask each party to state how they would go about it, then devise what you see as the best method; present back and discuss. Also anticipate barriers to success; using this to devise an alternative path(s)—being your Plans B, C, D…if needed.
- Implement and monitor. Set a schedule in writing, showing the dates and allocating responsibilities for the various tasks. Talk this through with the parties, including milestones and measures of success. Make progress reports if it is a long process. Look for learnings and opportunities to innovate and celebrate completion.
Reduction of stress and transition to collaboration are the ideal outcomes—for the co-operation of the involved parties and their ongoing relationship.