By Jeff Bell
Shared business ownership can be fraught with difficulty.
We know that in any partnership, when the romance fades, there is a power struggle where hopefully you come to terms with each other’s differences. The next stage could be true love.
If not, the possibility of separation will pose some serious questions. How is this done? Can the business survive? Who would take ownership?
These are matters for a shareholders’ agreement—drawn up at the beginning, probably when breaking up is the furthest thing from everyone’s mind.
Such an agreement will usually prohibit a shareholder selling their shares without first giving the other shareholders an opportunity to buy them—these are “pre-emptive rights”.
The intent is to ensure that the existing shareholders cannot be forced to accept an unwanted new shareholder. Usually they will have the right to buy the exiting shareholder’s shares—but this may not happen amicably.
A deadlock provision in a shareholders’ agreement may be invoked, in which the parties may be asked to summarise their differences in writing, and the sides may meet to try to find a resolution. The provisions may require a mediator or even an arbitrator.
If unsuccessful, they may resort to termination of the partnership. The underlying principles are that a successful business should not be destroyed because the partners are unable to agree and a way should be found for one party to withdraw with a reasonable return.
Consider these options:
- Mediation requires the amicable co-operation of both parties, facilitated by a skilled and empathetic and even-handed practitioner. However, the outcome may not be binding and the process is not guaranteed to produce a result. This is a very delicate beast and either party can walk away at any time.
- Arbitration is a more formal process whereby an arbitrator, having heard the evidence, makes a determination which is binding on both parties. Using this mechanism may keep the dispute confidential, but it may also be a lengthy and expensive, which may be onerous for the smaller business in particular.
- The Winding Up Sale allows a party to require the sale of all the assets of the business, paying creditors, distributing any remaining assets to the shareholders and then closing the business. However, unless there are keen bidders or if there is a negative market, significant value may be lost.
- The Tag Along clause is invoked when a majority shareholder or group of shareholders find a buyer for their shares. The minority shareholder then has the right to join the transaction and sell their minority stake in the company, should they wish to do so—or they may stick.
- The Drag Along clause allows a large shareholder(s) to include the other shareholders in a joint sale of the business. The smaller shareholders may be forced into the sale against their will. This may be coupled with a pre-emptive rights clause, allowing the minor shareholders to buy the business.
- Russian roulette. One of the two deadlocked parties serves a notice on the other, naming an all-cash price at which it values a half interest in the business. The receiving party then has the option to either buy out the other party or to sell to the other party.
- Texas shoot-out. Each party sends a sealed all-cash bid to an umpire stating the price at which they are willing to buy out the other party. The sealed bids are opened together, and the highest sealed bid wins, and that bidder must then buy and the loser must sell.
- Mexican shoot-out. Each party sends in sealed bids indicating the minimum price that they would be prepared to sell their half share. Whichever sealed bid is the higher wins and that bidder then buys the other party’s share at the price indicated in the other party’s sealed bid.
So, before pulling the pin, consider Neil Sedaka’s [modified] plea:
I beg of you don’t say goodbye
Can’t we give our business another try?
Come on, partner, let’s start anew
‘Cause breaking up is hard to do
Oh, what if a partner dies? The surviving partner may have the option to purchase the deceased partner’s interests at valuation.