Change in any place or time will naturally prompt caution, if not outright resistance.
It is situational, but it may also be personality-bound—for instance, subject to an individual’s capacity for optimism or pessimism.
As leaders, we need to keep in mind that resistance and resolution are at opposite ends of a continuum.
First, we need to detect resistance, then analyse the reasons for resistance and then develop a strategy to encourage resolution before actually getting that satisfactory outcome for all parties—if at all possible.
So how do we spot resistance to change?
When faced with what we perceive as a threatening situation, we can dig our heels in and refuse to climb the stairs. We may actively fight the threat—denying its influence on our world.
The problem is, as Carl Jung said:
What you resist not only persists, but will grow…
And unless we as leaders help others to rise above that reflex of resistance, it will all end in tears. We can’t help an involuntary clench of the stomach muscles when change is foreshadowed, but we can learn to relax and deal with it.
It’s about intent.
From a career-long experience of change design and implementation I have come up with what I call my Change Resistance Indicators. Understanding these may help you deal with resistance:
- Silence. When you open the doors to people’s reaction you may be hearing crickets. But never interpret silence as agreement. We need to encourage, even empower people to speak their mind about a change, without cause for fear.
- Passive resistance. People’s sense of duty may compel them to follow formal requests, but their real feelings will be revealed if and when they fail to turn up to meetings, or if they do, not participating in discussions. Look closely.
- Total “acceptance”. It may mean that, or it just may mean the opposite. People may feel so stressed that they will respond to the leader with what they want to hear but retreat to passive resistance or outright opposition.
- Violence. In this context, we mean verbal violence, but it may escalate to the physical. Someone may be so incensed by the change but have low emotional intelligence or negotiating skills. Look beyond the anger and find the fear.
- Absenteeism. Someone may feel so unable to cope with a change or to negotiate with the leader or change agent that they will completely remove themselves from the workplace, taking sick leave, leave of absence or precipitous long service leave.
- Retention. Rather than accept or co-operate with the mooted change, some will hold onto the old ways of doing things and refuse retraining or refuse outright to implement the new ways of doing things. When stressed, the familiar is comfortable.
- Slow responses. While speaking in support, or giving other outward signs of agreement, the delivery on the plan may betray discontent with what is required by the change. This may also include partial or non-completion of set tasks.
- Creating spotfires. These are minor (or major!) crises, not apparently connected to the main game, but that divert attention designed to rob the change program of its focus, energy, momentum, effectiveness or success. They may deserve attention, but not yours.
- Talking down change. When others are on board and success seems imminent, those with some other agenda or allegiance may seek to minimize the benefits, fail to give credit or even openly criticise the achievements, hoping to cause a retreat.
- Sabotaging change. Not satisfied with mere talk, the resistor may go further, precipitating a physical undoing of what has been achieved. The resistor may then be straying into the unethical or even the criminal, but such behaviour is to be anticipated and countered.
How do we help people deal with change? People will unerringly resist change if they don’t trust the message or the messenger or both. Their response to “what does it mean for me?” will be in the negative.
We need to explain our intent.
!