By Jeff Bell.
Strategic planning is a waste of time and effort.
That’s the inescapable conclusion for many people who have done it. And that’s enough for those skirting the fringes, flirting with commitment.
As a strategy facilitator myself, I have to agree.
That is, strategic planning in itself is never enough. If it is not followed by action, it certainly is a waste of time and effort. We need to raise our eyes to the horizon of implementation.
As one who gets motion sickness in the bath, I am not taken with yachting. But yachties know all about race day planning and they have an obsession with clean air—an apt analogy.
Once out on the water, it is essential to find a succession of lanes of relatively undisturbed air that are not being decelerated or disturbed by sails. Then you require the skills to find a lane that won’t be taken away from you by another boat, or at least not for a while.
Then you need to read the competing boats to windward to gauge whether you are being affected by them—not sailing into their dirty air. You need to work out where you want to go, anticipating the moves of your competitors in the prevailing conditions.
This is your plan. In the heat of the race, you need to tack below the leading pack in clean air, thinking ahead and looking for the best wind shifts—do you stay on course or do you tack away, putting others in your dirty air?
At all times, absorbing the race tension and the dynamics of the conditions, you need to remain calm to implement your plan.
In business, having a strategic plan without market sensitivity or follow up action is like just have a map of the course. We see the main features, the respective legs, the marker buoys, the distances, but all the dynamics of the conditions on race day are absent as is any data about your competition, let alone your race strategy.
So to be precise, planning is actually imperative and it must by served by a detailed, flexible and well-resourced action plan.
When you plan and implement activities:
- Your competition can ignore them (and you) or if engaging, has to accept your strategy and will try to counter it if you are enough of a threat to their success.
- Then you look for their counter and make the next move. This is where “No plan withstands first contact with the enemy”. The first potential shortcoming of your planning process becomes evident if you think that it can’t or won’t change tack. It must be changed, at least tactically, to maintain advantage over your competitor.
- You set the agenda and anyone else needs to keep up and fail or create their own plan…which means that you are still leading and setting the agenda.
[By the way, no-one outside the planning team needs to see all the workings of your plan. Those on your side of the game can see the structure and what you have ruled in and ruled out. Those outside can sit helplessly by as the outcomes become apparent. They will see the improvements, the lifts in performance and the changes in direction—months or years after the work you have put in.]
In all of this, you are creating the clean air, always for yourself.
But when you don’t plan and implement relentlessly, you:
- Hope for the best—which is pitiful.
- Allow your competitors to set the agenda and lead the race.
- Are forced to try to keep up with your competitors.
- Inevitably lag and get less than the best—lower margins, lower revenue, lower market share.
- Lose your followers, your supporters and your power.
- Have no time to reflect and create a different direction—you are not in control!
In this, you are breathing the dirty air and will not win.
Your best chances for success come when you are among your competition, subject to al the vagaries of the market shifts, finding the clean air—while the others have to get out of your way or suffer your dirty air.
Motion sickness? Don’t even think about it!