By Jeff Bell. Image: iStock.
Most of us scorn entitlement.
But aren’t we all entitled to something?
For instance, that we and our loved ones will have food, shelter, safety, access to education, health care and aged care— the first 2 levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs—when we work to create them directly or through our taxes. These are what we might call equitable entitlements.
There are also mandated entitlements—based on concepts of equality—from our government and legal system.
Entitlement can also be about social conventions such as treating people with respect or kindness or compassion. How much and when can be problematic and in this there is a significant situational component.
That is, in our recognition as a distinct group within the community,
People who have been denied any of the above entitlements and even mistreated or abused may be understandably strident in their claims to be treated the same as others. This is compounded when these people’s protests seem not be heard—the majority may be unaware, uncaring or even hostile to their perceived or demonstrable lack of equitableness.
Does this special sense of entitlement become a problem?
Especially when we feel that we are denied any of the above? This happens to the minority.
Eric Hoffer, who wrote the classic True Believers describes individuals who feel lost, ineffective, or alienated in their daily lives. They might be seeking to escape a sense of meaninglessness or a feeling of having lost something significant in their lives.
This feeling is particularly acute for indigenous people who have seen their culture and land overrun by an irrepressible presence. Now in the minority and against overwhelming odds, they feel the need to make themselves heard, recognised and entitled to at least the same outcomes as the majority.
When the minority makes itself heard, the majority most often digs in to maintain the status quo, and usually to ridicule the minority, leading to stifling neglect or outright persecution.
This happens because the majority culture automatically becomes a Persecutor, whether they realise it or not. They will be resented by the Victim minority. And then there is the Rescuer.
The Drama Triangle models the connection between responsibility and power in conflicts, and the destructive and shifting roles people play. Each role is not necessarily permanent, rather someone acting as one:
- The Persecutor’s stance is “It’s all your fault.” In any given situation, Persecutors may be controlling, blaming, critical, arrogant, angry, authoritarian, rigid and superior, their reality may be the only “truth”—or it may just may be how the Victim characterises them.
- The Victim’s stance is “Poor me!” Victims feel oppressed, helpless, hopeless, powerless, ashamed, and seem unable to make decisions, solve problems, take pleasure in life, or achieve insight. The Victims will seek out a Persecutor (the majority culture).
Then that third player joins the fray:
- The Rescuer’s stance is “Let me help you.” Rescuers feel guilty if they don’t take over. But this rescuing has negative effects: it keeps the Victims dependent and gives them permission to fail. This also means that the focus is taken off the Rescuers who will have their own anxiety and issues, disguised as concern for the Victim, but they will also perpetuate the Victims’ negative feelings.
These situations occur because each group gets their unexpressed needs met, without acknowledging the harm that they cause. Each player is acting selfishly, rather than as responsible Adults.
These positions get in the way of equitable outcomes for all people, particularly the minority groups.
Ideally, all parties move to what is known as the Adult ego-state, using their grown-up resources to:
- Help the Victims with problem solving—ask them “What is the ideal outcome; what are your options?” Urge the Victims to resist involving others.
- Nurture the Rescuers by asking “What are your options?” Discover their anxieties. Encourage them to have a conversation with the Victim on ideal outcome and options.
- Challenge the Persecutors to consciously build others up; to look for the learning in their own lives, to understand what difficulties the Victims are facing.
So, instead of perpetuating our majority or minority status, let’s try to understand the other party and be fair. If not, kind.