By Jeff Bell. Image by iStock
A man had twin sons—Stuart, a pessimist, and Pete, an optimist. On their 13th birthday, the father gave Stuart an expensive watch, a carpentry set and a bicycle. And Pete’s room…he filled with horse dung.
When Stuart opened his presents he grumbled all morning. He had not wanted a carpentry set, he didn’t like the watch and the bicycle had the wrong kind of tyres. When the father went to Pete’s room he couldn’t see him, but he could hear frantic shoveling and heavy breathing. Horse dung was flying all over the room.
“What in heaven’s name are you doing?” the father shouted.
Pete’s voice came from deep inside the dung. “Well father, if there’s so much shit around, there has to be a pony somewhere!”
This quirky anecdote in buried in the intricate and confronting novel by Arundhati Roy, The God of Small Things. It won the 1997 Booker Prize and is well worth a read. (She also wrote The Ministry of Utmost Happiness, which was long-listed in 2017.)
To even be in business, we need to be optimistic—even if it means being a shoveler.
Especially if it means being a shoveler.
Why?
Optimism is the force that drives superior performance, innovation and progress. It inspires followers and raises morale. To create success takes resourcefulness, talent and persistence. We must believe that we will triumph
Conversely, if we believe that none of this will bring us success, there it will be—the self-fulfilling prophesy.
Martin Seligman was disturbed by psychology’s obsession with pain and suffering—founded on the work of Sigmund Freud. Seligman and colleagues felt that life should be about seeking the positive.
This led him to the theory and practice of optimism and with it, the need to achieve mastery over bad events—
a mindset that the future is controllable.
In his earlier book, Learned Optimism, Seligman coined “explanatory style” to describe the way we habitually explain to ourselves why events happen. An optimistic explanatory style stops helplessness and even depression, whereas a pessimistic explanatory style spreads it.
The unshakable belief that you can succeed may be more important than what the facts, the logic, indicates.
He says that there is ample evidence to suggest that an optimistic mindset also leads to a boost to our immune system and therefore better health, can fast track our potential to success and lead us to a happier life.
In The Hope Circuit, Seligman described his model for developing an optimistic mindset and a happier life. Called PERMA, it includes Positive Emotions—encompassinghappiness, pleasure, and comfort which each serve as a marker for us to flourish and therefore are worth cultivating. Positive emotions can broaden our thought / action repertoire, which will in turn build enduring personal resources. Over time and experience our confidence in dealing with adversity grows.
As it is for the individual, so it is for the organisation. When this is our mindset as a leader, it creates energy and direction for all. It spreads from those we work with each day as a leader and it is carried forward by those people to others in the organisation. It is capable of being the greatest lever of the Leader by Influence (LBI). It will also have a significant effect on suppliers and customers.
But optimists (nearly every leader I have met) often underestimate the obstacles and the risks. Even having done a risk assessment, we may proceed with a blind expectation of success. If it comes off, we are vindicated, taking the credit and basking in the admiration of the beneficiaries.
And if the crash-through becomes a crash, we may put it down to bad luck and get up again. In fact, the greatest advantage of optimism, says Seligman, may be that it
provides enough of an illusion to overcome obstacles and recover from falls.
So it is also just a way of thinking and it is a bias at that. But we have a problem if and when we keep on at the impossible task—we expose ourselves and those we lead to greater risks and higher costs.
It will mostly serve us well, if used wisely.
Optimism is certainly our business.