Everyone finds themselves in transition at different times and to different degrees.
As a leader, you need to be on the ball if you wish to maintain a good relationship, let alone retain a valued member of your team.
On Mnday I revealed a model for identifying work transitions.
It is essential that, for those we lead and for ourselves, we think that we are constantly in transition—we are never not in one of the phases described below. To think otherwise means that we are more likely to be complacent, resistant to change, unwilling to learn and unlikely to spot innovation opportunities.
In each of the below phases, to open the conversation, the leader needs to make it safe—when the stakes are high! Offering safety to the other party will open up dialogue and hopefully lead to beneficial outcomes.Safety will be achieved in a conversation when we establish:
- mutual purpose—discovering the other person’s goals and explaining our own;
- mutual respect.
So, if you perceive that the person is in:
1. Optimism. It’s a new start—”Why did I hang around so long there? I made the right choice to leave. I am wanted after all—here! The work is interesting. The people are welcoming. There’s so much to learn. I’m really looking forward to this!” And you will have contributed to this optimism by presenting your company with rose coloured glasses.
Leader response: Provide a comprehensive induction program and a welcome pack. Reinforce the positives and provide an informal buddy. Ask for feedback: “Tell us, as a new arrival, what you see and what we could do to improve.”
2. Fear and threat. “Oh no, this is harder than I expected. Maybe I’m not what or who I thought I was. The old rules don’t apply and there are too many new rules here. People don’t seem so friendly anymore. I don’t have the same respect as before. Why did I do this? I feel disillusioned. Maybe I should be out of here?”
Leader response: “Let me remind you what we see in you. Every new start feels this “buyer’s remorse”. We have confidence in you and want you to succeed. What can I do to help you?”
3. Dejection and hostility. “I feel really bad about this now. What was I thinking? Who am I really? What can I do to get out of this?” This may morph into hostility and blame. “This isn’t right or fair. Why isn’t the boss helping me out more. They are so unsympathetic. Or maybe it’s my fault—I’m not OK.”
Leader response: “We have great respect for you and your capabilities. We believe that you have been a great acquisition to our team. Can I have your suggestions about what we could be doing for you and your customers.”
4. Acceptance and moving forward. “Some days are better than others; actually, I’m progressing. This can work and be good! I think that this is the right place for me after all. I can now see where and how I belong. People respect me and I am good at this work. I can now see a really good future for me!”
Leader response: “I appreciate that you have worked through some difficulties since joining us. My feeling is that this has made you an even more valuable team member. Would you be a buddy for one of the new starts?”
5. Disillusionment or complacency. They seem ill at ease, in conflict with others, out of humour, arriving late and leaving early each day and doing just enough to get by. Life in this role has become too comfortable and predicable—there is no longer any challenge. Frustrated or bored, they are beginning to search for a new role.
Leader response: “I see that you have mastered your role. We have been impressed by your contribution. Time for a new phase—I am proposing a training program in ‘x’, after which we would like you to take on ‘y’. Will you do it?”
y