By Jeff Bell.
When matters get serious, we tend to forgo our most potent weapon.
We dig our heels in. We double down. We refuse to give an inch.
And so does the other party.
The trouble with taking a mutually adversarial position is that it depletes both of us. Even in victory.
Whenever we find ourselves locking horns with someone, first we need to pause. Silence and calm have their own special power, particularly if accompanied by unwavering eye contact. This may be all that is needed. If so, we can move on.
Even if so, we need to interrogate our response–what is the threat we are experiencing? The chances are, we sense that something of value may be taken away from us: our tactical advantage; an asset; a relationship; our strategic advantage; our status, our place in the world.
Thirdly, we need to consider where the attack is coming from and what may be their motivation.
Fourthly, what is the content of the attack–what is being said or claimed. What are the facts and what are the feelings being conveyed? For most of us, these 4 events may happen within seconds and away we will go–reacting.
What are the lessons for our leadership?
In business, the degree to which adversarial positions are created will depend largely on which of 2 positions we take. Regular readers will be familiar with my model:
There is the leader who relies on Positional Power which stems from their title or rank: “I’m the boss, do what I say.” Such position comes from appointment, election or inheritance and can be easily taken back. This is leading by mandate.
The Leader by Mandate finds little room for humour–what space there is will probably be lacking in warmth or generosity and will probably employ irony, sarcasm or even ridicule. They will take themselves very seriously and as such, they will be a target for covert or even overt ridicule themselves.
Then there is the leader who relies on Personal Strength, which is made up of attributes and behaviours that make a person appealing to others, and these prevail, unless they are undermined by incongruent behaviour—like not keeping our word.
The uplifting and skillful use of influence inspires people to choose the cause that has been articulated by this Leader by Influence. A pleasant demeanour, an approachable manner and the frequent use of positive humour will be their personal brand.
So, what could be that most potent weapon?
In his literary crime novel Death of a Foreign Gentleman, Steven Carroll has his leading character put it this way:
“Laughter is the most powerful weapon against the powerful. Once we laugh at them, they are no longer serious. And they lose all their power.”
The LBM relies most heavily on the exercise of force, while the LBI leads with, and creates, strength. How do we recognise the difference between force and strength? The most telling may well be in their use of humour.
Force uses sarcasm and ridicule to keep people down and this will eventually erode that leader’s credibility and any affection they have built. Strength uses positive humour to inform, entertain and invigorate. This use of humour will elevate both leader and follower.
And this comes from not taking ourselvestoo seriously–which is a combination of humility and a certain lightness. I don’t mean the humility of “I don’t know anything”, but rather a case of “I don’t know everything”; and being able to maintain a sense of humour when the stakes are high, the tension is high—or both.
For a live case study, we may track the use of humour by the candidates in the upcoming US presidential election campaign. What form of humour is used, by whom and in what situations. He / she who can harness humour and can cause laughter–not to denigrate, but to uplift–I believe will be the winner.
As leaders ourselves, the way in which we use humour–our ability to generate positive laughter–will be our most revealing indicator of success.
For, as pianist-comedian Victor Borge said:
Laughter is the shortest distance between two people.