By Jeff Bell.
As fully-functioning, self-aware adults we are always engaged in one of three roles:
- Leader—this may be a mandated title, or just how we behave.
- Manager—this may also be a mandated title, and just how we behave.
- Mismanager (yes, this is a role—I claim credit for naming it). This will not be a mandated title and it will be just how we behave.
We will experience and perform in all three at various times in our day and throughout our life. How long we spend in each will define us in others’ eyes and form our own self-perception.
A Leader has voluntary followers. This following is driven by her inspirational messages, coupled to a great cause; with or without a mandated title.
A Leader doesn’t need to tell followers what to do, because they are inspired by the leader’s message, or charisma or both. The followers will be attracted by the promise of something more or better in their lives and they will divert energy from what they normally do to make it happen. They may also be prepared to put themselves at risk to achieve the leader’s vision.
The authentic leader will channel his ego needs into the cause, rather than himself. This leader is modest and willful, humble and fearless; and will give his followers credit for the eventual achievements. His appeal is to the heart.
The Leader is comfortable with risk and adversity and may even have experienced a major setback or trauma which has driven the leadership spirit in her. She will be a rule breaker and will use conflict creatively!
He will not be bound by what people think of him and may be socially aloof or even a loner. By definition, he is very good with people and is achievement-oriented.
The chief motivation in leadership is drawing people to that great cause, and in pursuit of this…
…the leader is driven by doing the right thing.
Incidentally, the Leader is not necessarily a leader in all situations or forever and may even cede control to someone better suited to a given situation.
However, the spirit and behaviour of leadership can be in anyone, at anytime, anywhere.
A Manager has subordinates in a mandated structure, telling subordinates what to do. These subordinates comply because there is a reward—salary and benefits.
This telling people what to do is an appeal to the head, rather than the heart.
The Manager will draw compliance, rather than inspire loyalty.
The Manager will seek to be close to the subordinates, demanding conformity and compliance with the agreed or required processes. There will be sanctions for not following the processes.
The Manager (who is herself a subordinate) will have constraints in time, resources and costs which she will also use to control or modify the behaviour of her subordinates.
The Manager will be risk-averse and will crave compliance. A good Manager’s subordinates will work happily and within the imposed limits. There will be short-term objectives, and if reached, the Managerwill take the credit.
There is no aloofness or mystique about the Manager, who will probably have come from a risk-averse background himself, prefer to remain within his comfort zone and will be very concerned about what people think of him.
Overwhelmingly, the Manager’s concern is doing things right.
But there is a limitation that many do not understand: the Manager controls physical resources and processes. Seeking to manage people causes resistance, damages morale and leads to poor performance.
A Mismanager willfully abandons the role of Manager or slides into neglect—neither of which is a pretty sight. Mostly, we do not aspire to be Mismanagers. Through lack or skill, or energy, or will, we may slide into the abyss—hopefully, only fleetingly.
*
As an executive coach, I see some Managers becoming Leaders. I also see the most successful Leaders applying crucial management behaviours.
And there is a piece here called self-management: we all need to be good managers of our own resources and processes.
If you find yourself reverting to Mismanager, I make the same suggestion as for the other two.
Coaching can be powerful for the three roles we play.