By Jeff Bell
Why would a business owner give an employee equity?
Sometimes as a coach and strategist, a client will ask me “What’s the best way to do this?”
My reflex is not a response to the “how?”, but to the “why?”.
To be fair, the owner will invariably have the best of intentions at heart. They will be motivated to retain a high performing and trusted employee, probably serving in an executive role, who they would like to develop and retain. There may also be a friendship factor.
They may also be motivated by the employee stating or implying: “We have done very well, so well that you have become enriched, while I am still limping along on salary and a Christmas bonus”.
If you are that business owner, you will be in a dilemma—so you need clear option generation, leading to a sound decision. You need to put this into perspective.
I have devised a set of questions to ask yourself. Your answers are for you:
- Did you start the business from scratch, did you buy it or was it handed to you through you family or some other relationship?
- How long was it before the business broke even? Was it in danger of collapse? How many years since then have been in the black?
- So, what has been the total investment or the financial cost to the present date? (This is by you and any other party.)
- What were the personal costs in building the business—the time spent by yourself (weekly average) and any unpaid time by family or friends?
- What has been your net return from the business in terms of salary and dividends, over the entire period? Plus an adjustment for inflation.
- How long has the employee been with you? What were the conditions of their hire? Were they to receive payments above the agreed salary?
- What has been the total salary, plus bonuses or profit share has the employee received since joining you? What is the industry benchmark?
- What has been the employee’s measurable contribution beyond their financial earnings? Have they gone above and beyond? Have there been light bulb achievements?
- What number and type of risks does the business face? Include the internal and external. What are the potential costs of disruption by each?
- Who is liable at law for these risks? Does the employee bear any? What protection do you have for any legal or financial claim?
- Who owns the assets in your business and what are they worth? Do you have asset protection structures that would automatically defend a claim?
- What is your market share and who are your strongest competitors? If you were them, what would you do to disrupt your business?
- What other employee motivation tools or incentives are at your disposal—besides equity? What would be the most appealing to this particular employee?
- What would be the consequences if you were to say “no” to equity? Consider both the positives and the negatives. Is there a win-win?
- Is the employee likely to “walk” if you say no? If so, what would be the net outcome if they were to be replaced?
- If the employee were to leave, would they likely be sought by your competitors? Do you already have a non-compete clause in their contract?
- If they did contemplate competition as an owner or part-owner, what would be their competitive advantages and barriers to entry in your industry?
- If you were to say “no” to equity and they stayed, is it possible that they could become a “white-ant”? Could this precipitate disruption?
- What would be the cost to you of legal and financial advice and procedures for any of the above that are not already covered?
- Considering your answers to the above questions, what compelling, nay, overwhelming reasons do you now have to hand over equity to your employee?
Finally, you may ask yourself, is there a sense of entitlement behind the request—”If you have, then I also deserve”. In reality, this is neither an argument nor a valid claim.
Now can you put this equity dilemma into perspective?
Choose.