By Jeff Bell.
Our international politico-economic outlook has been severely disrupted.
We can see the means being used—the threat and counter-threat of tariff protection—so what leadership behaviours are in play? What cause is being articulated and who are the intended beneficiaries? Are the tactics seeking to influence and unite, or divide and dominate?
I am seeing high ego, arrogance and wild decision-making, with little in the way of empathy, humility or vulnerability.
Excessive ego is poison to influential leadership. It is bound to foul the relationships that make business—or any human endeavour—enjoyable and worthwhile. We need to put ego aside in our quest for true connection.
Arrogance reaches beyond excessive ego. It relies on threat and bluster and it rarely delivers. Arrogance is fragile, fleeting and insubstantial. It may draw on anxiety—suspecting that I am not good enough, and I need to defeat others.
An arrogant person may be narcissistic and have low self-awareness. They are certainly lacking in humility, unable to achieve the perspective of: “Let me understand what I am up against.”
Without an appreciation of our own shortcomings and an understanding of the odds, especially those against, we’re at a severe disadvantage. Overestimating or overstating our capabilities, as well as underestimating the opposition, will invariably result in leadership disaster.
An arrogant person is also likely to be deficient in empathy—that is, seeking to understand the person they are speaking to, regardless of role, gender, race, religion, or sexual preference; acknowledging and respecting people, having deep conversations with all; treating them as considerately as they themselves would like to be treated.
Whereas self-confidence is based on knowledge, experience, insight and humility. It is calm and always delivers, it is secure, enduring and substantial. It has the composure of: I am good enough, without having to compete with or denigrate others.
A self-confident person is aware of their own value and the value of others, never claiming to be above them.
And, the humble leader embraces vulnerability, speaking up for beliefs-regardless of personal risk or danger—and takes action. They will seek to lift up those who have suffered oppression and disadvantage, those who lack power, resources or hope.
And how else does vulnerability show up?
- Leadership involves taking crucial choices—deciding what is right over what is comfortable. Therefore, the leader will set the agenda and show courage to risk disagreement, especially when outnumbered—persuading people to our point-of-view. This will almost certainly involve significant personal risk.
- The leader needs to hold fast. The leader chooses what is right over popularity, needing the courage to stand alone, because waiting to see which way the wind blows before speaking up is craven. We need to shape, not echo, public opinion.
- The leader needs to challenge the status quo. A cause arises from abuse or neglect by the majority—most of whom will have a vested interest in maintaining hierarchies, processes and practices which will mostly stand in the way of the cause.
The capacity for a leader to be vulnerable is based on deeply held values which drive behaviours,
the outcome of which is the holy grail: trust.
Here are some behaviours that demonstrate vulnerability:
- We see that we always have something to learn.
- We are open to being challenged by anyone.
- We represent ourselves and our capabilities without embellishment.
- We surrender any positional power, relying instead on personal influence.
- We seek to learn from our competitors’ strengths.
- We help those who speak the truth at their own expense.
- We hold our position in the face of an attack.
- We are able to admit to our mistakes.
- We are open to challenge on our own values.
- We do what we say we will do.
And while crafting strategy, do we: seek to first deeply understand; create options; involve trusted others; before we choose? When negotiating, do we: create the win-win; marshal our allies; show the other side respect; retain our dignity; consider the inevitable unintended side-effects?
I believe that many current world leaders are a long way from humility and vulnerability.
ll the more reason for us to build that trusted leadership.