By Jeff Bell.
When we are protesting, are we seeking to put things right?
Or are we seeking just to be heard?
Here’s an hypothetical: a national sporting team appeals for sponsorship and a benefactor steps up.
But members of the team are alerted to something that the benefactor’s father said several decades earlier. A team member takes umbrage on behalf of her race and the community in general.
The fellow-team members act in solidarity; the team declines the support. A statement has been made, the protest has been heard.
I would not advocate for either side in such a dispute—both have their merits; and their shortcomings. The trouble is, when we call someone out for a misdemeanour, we are making them wrong. Pursuing their own agendas…
…the parties are on a win-lose path.
The protesters gain attention and followers by naming the perpetrator (aka the benefactor) and detailing their misdemeanour(s). This is a win for the protester—they have recognition and right on their side. The perpetrator stands accused—so, where there is smoke… This is a lose for the perpetrator.
The protesters now move into rescuing those oppressed by the perpetrator. Because the oppressed are dispossessed, the protestors will do all the talking and provide the energy required to put this right. Another win for the protestors, still a lose for the benefactor, who is on the back foot.
Maintaining the rage and “doing the right thing” adds to the protesters’ momentum and boosts their ego—so many people are watching and agreeing! We still haven’t heard from the persecutor. Another win for the protestors; still a lose for the benefactor.
[To tell the truth, the protesters themselves feel a deep hurt and discrepancy. They too are downtrodden and they too have failed to take action to fill a yawning gap in their lives. Sticking up for someone else diverts attention from their own hurt. Mark that as a half-win. Perpetrator? Still a lose.]
Finally, recovering from the surprise of the attack, the benefactor re-states their offer and appeals to the higher cause of national glory. Theirs is generosity personified which needs acknowledgement; the benefactor has become the victim! Mark this as a win. And a lose for the mean-spirited protesters.
The protesters can keep on protesting in the hope that they will win out—serve and repeat. But the benefactor, still rebuffed, takes umbrage and the offer is withdrawn. That will show them—ingrates!
Now nobody has won—the team is without the sorely needed funds and the sponsor will receive none of the reflected success of the team.
If it’s not too late, let’s try a different—a leaderful—approach:
- Engage a mediator. Find a calm and trustworthy outsider—someone with the right skill set, emotional intelligence and no vested interest who can walk everyone through the following steps to the process, to bring everyone to an acceptable resolution.
- Leave the past. We can’t change what’s happened. But we can create fairness in the here and now. Let’s find a new way for us to behave with each other that will ensure we both have our needs met.
- Players, give up being right. An over-reliance on ego can do a lot of damage as it struggles with pride, fear and endless want. Ego has an insatiable appetite and a constant need for defence. Let it go.
- Don’t get personal. It’s easy to take the other party on face value—danger! Confine yourself to talking about what is said and what is done. Get clarification and a deeper understanding. No name calling, finger pointing or personal attacks.
- Find a process. Players, restate your intent—what did each want before this blew up? Each party listens to the other and then repeats what they heard. Each party adds anything that the other party has missed. Devise and choose options.
Is there enough for the parties to strive for the common goal? If so, formalise, communicate and get it done. If not, each party may acknowledge the other’s intent and courage and walk away.
Whatever the outcome, we have moved beyond protest, to striving for the possibility of putting things right.